☀️ Solar Comparison

On-Site Solar vs Community Solar Subscription

Own the panels and claim the 30% ITC — or subscribe to community solar with zero capital and instant savings? The right choice depends on whether you own or lease your building, your tax position, and your time horizon.

Upfront Capital
Community Solar wins
20-Year Savings
On-Site wins
Tax Incentives
On-Site wins
Speed to Savings
Community Solar wins
Best for Tenants
Community Solar wins

Side-by-Side Comparison

Based on a 200 kW commercial solar scenario with average commercial electricity rate of $0.12/kWh.

🏗️ On-Site Solar (Owned) 🌱 Community Solar Subscription
Upfront Capital (200 kW) $500,000 – $700,000 $0 — no capital required
Net Cost After 30% ITC $350,000 – $490,000 net N/A
MACRS 5-Year Depreciation ~$100k–$140k additional tax savings Not applicable
Annual Bill Savings $29,000 – $43,000/yr (full offset) $1,200 – $4,800/yr (5–15% discount)
Simple Payback Period 5–8 years (post-ITC + MACRS) Immediate savings, no payback needed
20-Year Net Savings $230,000 – $560,000 $24,000 – $96,000
Requires Roof Ownership Yes — suitable roof required No — off-site installation
Installation Time 3–9 months (permitting + install) 2–8 weeks (paperwork only)
Available to Tenants Generally no Yes — any commercial utility customer
ESG / RECs Own RECs — full Scope 2 credit RECs vary by program; confirm with provider
Maintenance Responsibility Owner (or O&M contract, $0.005–0.01/kWh) None — developer maintains project
Transferability Asset stays with property (adds value) Transferable within utility territory

Pros & Cons Deep Dive

🏗️ On-Site Solar (Owned)
Pros
  • 30% ITC directly reduces federal tax liability
  • MACRS 5-year accelerated depreciation (effective ~10% additional savings)
  • Full electricity offset — avoid $0.10–$0.16/kWh market rates for 25+ years
  • Own RECs — creditable toward Scope 2 emission reductions
  • Adds asset value — solar increases commercial property value 3–4%
  • Pairs with battery storage for demand charge reduction
Cons
  • Large upfront capital ($2.50–$3.50/W installed)
  • Requires suitable roof area, structural load capacity, and low shading
  • 3–9 month installation timeline with permitting
  • Not available to tenants or leased buildings without complex PPA structures
  • Must have sufficient tax appetite to monetize ITC
🌱 Community Solar Subscription
Pros
  • Zero upfront cost — savings from day one
  • No roof, structural, or permitting requirements
  • Available to renters, tenants, and multi-site portfolios
  • Fast enrollment — typically 2–8 weeks to activation
  • Flexible — most contracts allow cancellation with 30–90 days notice
  • Supports local renewable development in your grid region
Cons
  • Savings limited to 5–15% bill discount (not full offset)
  • Cannot directly claim ITC or MACRS depreciation
  • Availability limited to states with community solar programs (~30 states)
  • REC ownership varies — verify program terms for ESG credit
  • 20-year total savings 5–8× lower than on-site ownership

Which Option Fits Your Situation?

🏗️ Choose On-Site Solar If…

  • You own the building and have 10+ year horizon
  • Roof area can support 100 kW+ system with minimal shading
  • You have federal tax liability to monetize the 30% ITC
  • ESG strategy requires full Scope 2 REC ownership
  • You want to pair with battery storage for demand savings
  • LCOE after payback is $0.01–$0.03/kWh — unbeatable rate

🌱 Choose Community Solar If…

  • You lease your space or have a short-term occupancy
  • Building roof is unsuitable (HVAC equipment, low capacity)
  • You want immediate savings with zero capital deployment
  • Operating in a community solar state (CA, NY, IL, MA, MN, etc.)
  • Portfolio of 10+ locations — subscribe each to local projects
  • No tax equity capacity to monetize ITC internally

Frequently Asked Questions

Can commercial buildings subscribe to community solar?
Yes. Most community solar programs accept commercial customers. Subscriptions are typically sized by kW or as a percentage of your annual electricity usage. Most programs allow subscriptions of 100 kW–5 MW, though availability varies by state. Commercial subscribers typically receive 5–15% bill credits applied directly to their utility invoice.
What is the payback period for commercial on-site solar?
With the 30% ITC and MACRS 5-year depreciation, commercial on-site solar projects typically achieve a 5–8 year simple payback. Without incentives the payback is 9–14 years. After payback, solar generates electricity at approximately $0.01–$0.03/kWh marginal cost (O&M only) for the remaining 20+ years of panel life — a significant competitive advantage.
Does community solar qualify for the ITC?
Community solar subscribers do not directly claim the ITC — the project owner (developer) claims it. However, the ITC savings are typically passed through to subscribers as lower subscription rates. If you want to directly claim the 30% ITC, you need to own the on-site system, either outright or through a direct ownership structure like a direct ownership PPA with your entity as the system owner.
What happens if we move or close the building?
Community solar subscriptions are typically transferable to another building in the same utility territory, or cancellable with 30–90 days notice (terms vary by contract). On-site solar is a physical asset attached to your building — it stays with the property and adds resale value. Panels can technically be relocated but at significant cost, making it impractical for most commercial moves.
Which option is better for a building we lease vs own?
Tenants and building lessees are almost always better served by community solar, since they cannot install permanent equipment and ITC pass-through to tenants requires complex lease structures. Building owners benefit most from on-site solar due to direct ITC, MACRS depreciation, and property value appreciation of 3–4% typically observed in commercial real estate.

Model Your Solar Economics in 10 Minutes

Our free energy audit shows your roof capacity, 30% ITC savings, and side-by-side payback vs community solar — with your actual utility rates.

Related Comparisons